patching...
Breaking: Coaching Marathon Changed Due To Weather »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

PA Imposes Moratorium on Gas Drilling in Northern Chester Co

The provision halting fracking was attached to a state budget measure which lawmakers approved late Saturday night.

 

Companies that want to drill for natural gas will have to wait.

State lawmakers on Saturday night approved a moratorium on gas drilling in Bucks, Montgomery and parts of Lehigh, Berks and Chester counties. The moratorium will affect any oil or gas operations in the South Newark Basin, which underlies a swath of territory extending from Bucks through Chester and into Berks County.

Do you agree with the moratorium? Tell us in the comments.

The moratorium is needed so scientists and engineers can better study the gas deposits held deep below ground, lawmakers said Saturday.

It was passed as an amendment to the state's fiscal code, in SB 1263. (Click here to read the full text of the bill or for more information.)

The state House and Senate approved the budget late Saturday and Gov. Tom Corbett signed it just before midnight, the end of the state's current fiscal year.

Background on Area Geology

A 2011 report from the United States Geologic Survey outlined the results of surveys of five basins along the east coast, from northern New Jersey down to North Carolina. The study was released on June 20, 2012.

One of those basins, the South Newark Basin, underlies much of Bucks and Montgomery counties, according to the report. Geologists estimate that basin contains at least 363 billion cubic feet of undiscovered natural gas deposits, and could contain much more. They estimated the mean amount to be 876 billion cubic feet.

The five basins together hold an estimated mean natural gas resource of 3,860 billion cubic feet, the report concluded.

Confronted with evidence that gas drilling could, indeed, affect the area, lawmakers scrambled to amend Act 13, the controversial state law regulating drilling in the Marcellus Shale formation.

The technique drilling companies use to fracture the rock formation to release the gas, called fracking, has faced stiff opposition from those worried about the environmental and health affects of the practice.

"The recent report by USGS has shed a new light on the possible circumstances in Bucks and other southeast PA counties. We believe it is necessary, given this new information, that these counties must be given the opportunity to have a greater say about things happening in their own backyard," Mensch said in the joint statement. "Originally Act 13 was viewed as primarily an issue for the northern tier counties. This new information proves otherwise."

Reaction

But while the moratorium exempts Chester and the other areas in the South Newark Basin from drilling for now, other parts of the state still must comply with Act 13. Some characterized it as a move by legislators in a wealthy part of the state to protect their backyards, while leaving other Pennsylvanians unprotected.

"Where was our study? Where was our six years?" Democratic Rep. Jesse White was quoted as saying in the Pittsburgh Post Gazette. "What makes Bucks and Montgomery [counties] so special?"

White represents part of Washington County, on the far western Pennsylvania border, an area that hosts "a significant amount of Marcellus Shale drilling," according to the Pittsburgh newspaper.

The moratorium could run as long as six years, John Micek, The Morning Call's state politics reporter in Harrisburg, reported on the blog, Capitol Ideas. The addendum prevents drilling permits from being issued until a state study of the formation is completed, or until 2018, whichever comes first.

Related Topics: Act 13, Marcellus Shale, South Newark Basin, fracking, and natural gas drilling

Jared

8:22 am on Monday, July 2, 2012

If we allow them to drill it will be the biggest mistake we ever made! Do your homework and research whats going on in the northern tier of our state. Better yet ask someone who lives there!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Locally Involved

12:14 pm on Tuesday, July 17, 2012

@david reilly: 100% safe? There is nothing that is 100% safe. I work in the energy industry, 100% safe is not achievable. Given the 20+ years of data we have in our own country as well as global data - scientific fact, nothing soft and fuzzy - there is absolute reason for concern. Nothing can nor should happen until those concerns are duly addressed,

Altje Hoekstra

8:30 am on Monday, July 2, 2012

There should be a moratorium everywhere! Let's start putting money into renewable energy and stop destroying our water supplies!

Reply

JK

8:45 am on Monday, July 2, 2012

Dead on Hoekstra. I hear Solyndra is a worthy investment!

Reply

ed r.

10:18 am on Monday, July 2, 2012

I am tired of people making this a partisan issue. We need to agree, as living, breathing, and water drinking humans that the public health and safety impacts of gas drilling are deeply troubling.

Reply
Comment_arrow

PLD220

2:57 pm on Monday, July 2, 2012

Ed - You are speaking the truth, brother! People should want a safe environment for their children. As the father of a newborn, I couldn't imagine letting anyone pollute our drinking water. We need to invest in clean energy, like wind and solar.

Liz Rosenbaum

2:41 pm on Monday, July 2, 2012

Join the Movement to protect our land, air and water from the ravages of industrial shale gas drilling - Saturday, July 28, 2012, Washington DC
StopTheFrackAttack.org

Reply

Marcellus Shale

6:46 pm on Monday, July 2, 2012

join the clean air council, frack action, food and water watch, catskill mountain keeper, catskill river keeper,....in support of a frack-free world

Reply

Jeanne Alleva

7:34 pm on Monday, July 2, 2012

Thrilled with this decision!! Step in the right direction...so happy.

Reply

Louis Flanagan

7:54 am on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Fracking has been found to cause no harm to water supplies in Pennsylvania. As for renewables, only the very wealthiest could afford to pay for the energy they produce, unless produced by dams. And I don't wish to see more dams built.

In speaking with a resident of Bradford County, he says the only problems there consist of endless caravans of water trucks coming through town to deliver water to drilling sites. Secondly, many of the drillers have come from oil drilling states and they've been followed by enterprising women who have now set up shop in some of the towns.

Once the wells are completed, those two problems go away.

Reply

Liz Rosenbaum

10:14 am on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

According to gas industry estimates, the best cement wellbore seals will fail in 70-100 years. Is the industry going to return to replug all those wells for the rest of the watershed's lifespan? Hydro-geologists estimate the Delaware River Watershed has about a million more years. Unless, of course, we drain it dry for fracking, because once water is removed for shale gas drilling, it cannot be safely returned. "Recycling" waste water refers to using it to frack new wells.

Louis, if you need proof that shale gas drilling destroys water supplies, I suggest you listen to the people who have been adversely effected by spills, leaks, off-gassing, air pollution and methane contamination. They live in Bradford, Washington, Susquehanna, Butler and many other counties, and their video testimonials are readily available on the internet. Decide for yourself if you really think that many people from disparate corners of the state, and the world, are conspiring to make up one big lie about shale gas pollution. If you think so, then you must also believe that the sky is pink.

Reply
Comment_arrow

ed r.

10:26 am on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Liz, this is a great point. It's also a matter of what we know now, and what don't we know yet about the long term effects of this drilling. Water supplies are still feeling the effects of the industrial revolution. Know why you can't swim in any lakes in this part of PA? Part of the reason is mine run off from old coal mines. Did those companies stick around long enough to remedy the damage?

I don't want to gamble the health and well being of my future descendants to save a couple bucks on my heating bill.

Jared

10:28 am on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Right on Liz!

Louis not all renewable energy is only for the rich. Actually you can get 15% wind power at a cheaper rate from energy cooperative than Peco's standard rate. I'd recommend checking out their site. http://www.theenergy.coop/Electricity/electricity.htm

I switched and not only am I saving money but a portion of my electric now comes from PA wind farms.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Liz Rosenbaum

7:43 am on Saturday, July 7, 2012

thank you! i have been looking for this kind of local info as we attempt to liberate our household from the grid

Earnest

12:45 pm on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Question...If Act 13 was signed into law in the first place, who voted YEA, that has now voted for the (6) year moratorium?

Question...Why didn't any other county in PA also get a (6) year moratorium for "scientific study"?

Question...Who will be doing the "scientific study" the gas and oil companies that did residents well water studies, and claimed that there was no proof that the drilling contaminated their wells, even though their well water was potable prior to the drilling and previous testing done by local testers have reports of good drinking water conditions of those residents wells, prior to the drilling.

Question...If resident wells were deemed potable drinking water prior to the drilling how could the gas industries "scientific study" deny poisoning the residents wells?
Answer to this question...Residents must have their wells tested by the industries people, which residents had know knowledge.

Question...What happens if my neighbor OK's their land for drilling and it causes damage to my property, poisons my well? etc.? Who pays for the clean up and pays for potable water tanks and water to be shipped to my home? Who covers the loss of my property value? Will it be the company or will it be the neighbor? Who will go bankrupt first, the company or the neighbor?

Question...Drilling is horizontal. How do you know they are not blasting shale under your property without permission?

Reply

Earnest

1:15 pm on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

The Oil and Gas Law (Act 13) eviscerates local input and control. It denies the rights of local citizens to due process and protection of basic fundamental rights.

Under the Oil and Gas Law (Act 13) PA communities are not able to shield against any harms even in residential areas. Towns could have to allow frack well sites and toxic impoundment pits as close as 300ft. from a home, school, or hospital. How many local communities have the money to fight this in court?

Act 13 also gags physicians who may be treating an illness related to industry drilling.

Ligonier Township writes the following in their challenge to The Oil and Gas Law (Act 13): "Violates the underpinnings of our representative form of government. Precludes local (elected) officials from being responsive to the desires of their constituents regarding land use planning."

Some History: The Federal Energy Policy Act of 2005 contained a provision that is known as the "Haliburton Loophole", which exempted gas drilling and extraction from requirements in the underground injection control (UIC) program of the Safe Drinking Water Act. The Loophole also exempts these companies from the Clean Air Act, and the Clean Water Act.

Consistently, drilling companies have refused to provide a (comprehensive) list of chemical additives used in tracking fluid. They claim "states secrets" for their reasoning. Among those chemicals that they have provide are known carcinogens.

Reply

David Curran

1:21 pm on Tuesday, July 3, 2012

The magnitude of these deposits is truly amazing, and should be considered a blessing. I do feel the moratorium is a good idea however. These deposits are not going to go anywhere. As a society we should proceed with extreme caution not extreme greed extracting these resources.

Reply

Nick

10:45 am on Thursday, July 5, 2012

I completely support the moratorium. The impacts of drilling are just too serious to not fully consider them first. take your time, keep it safe and keep it as minimally invasive as possible the gas isn't going anywhere. check out shalestuff.com for more.

Reply

Locally Involved

8:18 pm on Friday, July 6, 2012

Many locals believe in so. Virginia that last year's unprecedented earthquake (there are no fault lines where the quake occured in Mineral, VA) was indeed instigated by the fracking wells in the area. Interesting, OK use to get 50 or so 2.0 earthquakes a year. Since fracking began a decade or so ago, that has increased to over 500. Here's what bloomberg news has to say: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-04-12/earthquake-outbreak-in-central-u-s-tied-to-drilling-wastewater.html

Surprised when I looked up this subject that Europe has moved onto ban fracking in many areas - Britain is not as accustomed to earthquakes, so when the arose along with fracking, the took the same, smart measures as our area.

Let's face it, carbon fuel is so last century. America has always grown when we invested in new technologies - whether it was the transistor or the pc - just look at how well the economy did. It'd be awesome to put the same vision behind sustainable, renewable resources.

Was amazed the other week as I headed up to our coal region. There along the ridge in Centralia, the town dessimated by a coal mine fire, there along that ridge, incredible wind mills. If a coal town can make the change, so can we!

Reply

.

2:15 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

This is simply a NIMBY solution. We in Montgomery, Lehigh, Berks and Chester counties are are the wealthiest areas in the state and can push our elected officials to not allow drilling. Meanwhile the poor hillbillies in the north and west of PA have no choice but to see their land and water ruined as their officials sell out to the drillers. They are leasing and selling their land for pennies on the dollar because they can barely put food on the table.

Corbett knows darn well he has NO CHANCE to win re-election if he can't carry Mont Co. and Chester County. He also knows he would lose those areas if he allowed drilling to take place there as even fellow Republicans would bulk at their water being poluted.

Money talks plain and simple. ANYONE who doesn't work in the energy industry who votes for Corbett next time around is either a brainwashed moron or partisan fool.

Reply

Liz Rosenbaum

2:35 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Hi Richard, You don't really think people in Montgomery, Lehigh, Berks and Chester counties will ignore the plight of our "hillbillie" neighbors? Most people I speak to are very alarmed by the heavy industrialization in our state. And despite the wealth of their districts, legislators in the east have typically been opposed, and outmaneuvered, by their western counterparts. It's absolutely key for people in this region to pay great attention to what's happening in Pennsylvnia's "Sacrifice Zone."

Reply
Comment_arrow

.

3:10 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Liz, Corbett campaigned on the platform of expanding drilling and won by an easy margin. Most of the Republicans in this area could care less about anyone but themselves. Hopefully enough people have now seen the light but by 2014 the damage will already be done to our "hillbillie" neighbors. Elections have consquences.

Leave a comment